Document Sub-committee: To promote a consistent documentation across both the Akraino level and all individual Blueprint Families through both the Akraino Wiki and specific whitepapers.
Please join the Documentation Sub-Committee mail list by self-adding within the Akraino Mail List Sub-Groups page.
Sub-Committee Chair: Ike Alisson elected for one year.
Meeting Details:
Akraino Edge Stack 1 is inviting you to a scheduled Zoom meeting.
Topic: Documentation and Release Planning
Time: Sep 25, 2020 07:00 AM Pacific Time (US and Canada)
Every week on Fri, until Sep 3, 2021, 50 occurrence(s)
Please download and import the following iCalendar (.ics) files to your calendar system.
Weekly: https://zoom.us/meeting/u5Esc-uhqDwqDEmrwbuc-hTf4Jwhm-b0VQ/ics?icsToken=98tyKu-trz8oE9KSsFyCd7UqW5nlb9_2k1Vrp7FKngrmTihnZFfcIepPf7AvJumB
Join Zoom Meeting
https://zoom.us/j/651429670?pwd=QW16NGJXTmdUNHVVK3FXbkxKV3ZnUT09
Meeting ID: 651 429 670
Passcode: 883460
One tap mobile
+16699006833,,651429670# US (San Jose)
+12532158782,,651429670# US (Tacoma)
Dial by your location
+1 669 900 6833 US (San Jose)
+1 253 215 8782 US (Tacoma)
+1 346 248 7799 US (Houston)
+1 646 558 8656 US (New York)
+1 301 715 8592 US (Germantown)
+1 312 626 6799 US (Chicago)
855 880 1246 US Toll-free
877 369 0926 US Toll-free
+1 587 328 1099 Canada
+1 647 374 4685 Canada
+1 647 558 0588 Canada
+1 778 907 2071 Canada
+1 204 272 7920 Canada
+1 438 809 7799 Canada
855 703 8985 Canada Toll-free
Meeting ID: 651 429 670
Find your local number: https://zoom.us/u/abS2XFh8ku
Note: Election Nov 5 2020- Unfortunately Samir has notified the TSC that he will not be able to continue as Chair. Thus we are opening up the self-nomination process. Please put a Y in the Self-nomination column if you wish to be chair. If not, please put an N. This process will go until Noon on 12 Nov (Pacific time). If there is only one self nominee then that person will become chair. If there are two or more, we will have an election.
Interested parties sign up:
Name | Affiliation | LF ID | Self-Nominate for Chair (Y/N) | Bio | Picture | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tina Tsou | Arm | tina.tsou@arm.com | ||||
James Williams | AT&T | jw4099@att.com | ||||
sujata tibrewala | Intel | sujata.tibrewala@intel.com | sujata tibrewala | |||
Samir Chatterjee | Rebaca | |||||
Pradnesh Dange | Rebaca | pradnesh.dange@rebaca.com | ||||
Arif Khan | Parser Labs | arif@parserlabs.com | ||||
Ike Alisson | ALICON Sweden | ike@alicon.se | Ike Alisson | Y |
Agenda
1/ 7:00 am – 7:15 am The AI Edge: School/Education Video Security Monitoring, Hechun Zhang
2/ 7:15 am – 7:30 am
3/ 7:30 am- 7:45 am
4/ 7:45 am – 8:00 am
Meeting notes:
Prepared documentatio is very thorough with detailed information onArchitecture, APIs, Security, Testing (including) fall back.The Blueprint team, Hencun and Lya yu, were very well prepared.
During the review, there had been made minor remarks related to:
The Blueprint AI Edge: School/Eductation Video Security Monitoring presented documentation fulfills the Akraino Documentation Sub-committee requirements. Therein, the Sub-committee recommends to the Akraino Process committee to accept the Blueprint submitted Documentation to the Akraino Sub-committee on Friday, November 20th, 2020.
12/04 schedule
Regular session:
1/ 7:00 am – 7:15 am PDT- The AI Edge: Federated ML application at edge zifan wu
2/7:15 am – 7:30 am - Radio Edge Cloud Documentation Paul Carver
3/ 7:30 am- 7:45 am- Predictive Maintenance (with a Thermal Imaging Camera, vibration sensors, etc.)
4/ 7:45 am – 8:00 am - Release 4 Documentation - Enterprise Applications on Lightweight 5G Telco Edge (EALTEdge)
Meeting Notes:
On Friday, 12/04, there had been a substantial failure in planing BPs review. There could be made review only of the BP on Lightweight 5G Telco Edge (EALTEdge). For ther other 3 (three) BPs, the following had been indicated briefly during the session:
- to update the Akraino logo with the latest one without the term "Edge Stack" to avoid infringement rights violation
- to refer explicitly to the BPs through which 5G connectivity is provided and the BP Enterprise Application works as currently there is an indication on the respective BP Family. It is also recommended to provide a reference to an internal Road Map development when it is tentativel plannes (in the Road Map, e.g. Q2 2021 or Q3, 2021) to deliver the intergation so that recipeients know that there is a preliminary plan for the BPs connectivity to 5G as indicated in the BP and threin E2E functionality compliance.
- to verify with the Akraino API subcommittee about the BPs reference to ETSI MEC MEP internal references to be denoted/treated as APIs
- the above remark on the APIs and possible mismatch between "ETSI MEC MEP internal inerfaces (3 groups on defined as Mx (external), Mp (internal) and Mm (on Management) is related to explicit indication on any APis that are used whether being compliant to Open API initiative 3.0 (on Open APis.org).
Since the respective documentation review of 1 (one) BP took a whole hour and it was inidcated that previously, there had been provided time slots only for 2 BPs Documentaiton Review during a Documentation Sub.committee review, the previous procedure to ´have 2 (two) BPs documentation review per TSC session is reinforced.
12/11 schedule
1/ 7:00 am – 7:15 am PDT- Intergrated Cloud Native Kuralamudhan Ramakrishnan
2/7:15 am – 7:30 am - Network Cloud with Tungsten Fabric Sukhdev Kapur
3/ 7:30 am- 7:45 am- IEC Type 4 AR/VR Bart Dong
4/ 7:45 am – 8:00 am - Connected Vehicle Blueprint(Aka CVB) Tao Wang
Meeting Notes:
There were conducted 2 reviews, namely BP IEC Type 4 AR/VR and BP Connected Vehicles (Aka CVB). Both BPs are in co-operation. CVB PTL, Tao Wang elaborated on the issue/status with the BPs APIs and that it had already been reviewed/discussed with the Akraino TSC API Sub-committee and agreed on it. No major issues in the documentation. There had been conveyed a remark on elaborating the status with the UC(s) so that the reader is aware where the BPs are used.
It is recommended to the Akraino Process committee and Akraino TSC to further proceed with the respective two (2) BPs submitted documentation for Akraino Rel. 4.
12/18 schedule
1/ 7:00 am – 7:30 am PDT
1/8/2021 schedule
1/ 7:00 am – 7:30 am PDT Public Cloud Edge Interface (PCEI) Blueprint Family Oleg Berzin
Meeting notes:
The following remarks shall be treated as "recommendations" pursuing enhancements/improvements and in no way treated as "mandatory" to follow and/or implement.
As the Zoom session could not be started on time and it took about 20 min to re-schedule the Zoom meeting, it was decided per mail to convey the remarks of Documentation review per mail. The following is recommended:
2. On the attached Data sheet, to check on page 2, whether it should be "PCEI in Akraino Rel 4" (as the indicated term is probably a typing mistake, if not to elaborate what the indicated term means)?
3. In the Test Document, there is very limited information about performed tests (except for the Bluval) and even in the part on the tests related to APIs there is not provided any information except the inidication that this is a work in progress. It is recommended to provide a reference to either a Time Plan and/or Road Map indicating when the Testing is scheduled for (e.g. Q1 or Q2, 2021).
On your comment and inquiry on my remark about "Maturity of the Solution", I am sorry if I had been ambigous and/or misleading with my remark.
I meant about the status of Deployment Availability in terms of
1. "Concept" or
2. "Demo" or
3. "Commercial Deployment".
I suggest that with regard to the variety of preferences in terms of having a "Concept" that can be further built-upon (please read "Customized") or a "Demo", that provides a working SW/Functionality (that is "stable") or a Commercial Deployment that can be taken as it is (with integration to BSS/peripheral internal Platforms) to be deployed fast in order to be shown as a reference on the Market.
Such denomination (anyone of the listed 3 above) on the status of the "Solution Deployment Availability", depending on the party the Solution is discussed with, can provide opportunities.
Again, I would like to convey from my side that it is a remark-suggestion, rather than a requrement.
On the "Demo" elaboration, I suggest to people to elaborate about it in the "Architecture" documents as it is read by the Technical people, that provide recommendations to the Commercial people.
On the UPF deployment, please note that UPF might be deployed at the DC, Aggregation Point, BTS and/or 5G CN (Core Network) site.
There are certain conditions for that.
In your PCEI case, you chose DC. If you get some questions on that from people who are aware and work with that (that aso know the conditions, differences, requirements), depending on your answer, recipients of your answer, may measure your insights into various aspects that this issue concerns/relates to.
Just FYI.
The digram below may provide you with an insight about the use of the terms CSPs and Telco (difference) with regard to the presented by 3GPP High-level model of roles.
The below chart assigns a particular meaning in the Case of (5G NSA/SBA) Slicing (SST/SSI) deployment (NSaaS).
P.S. According to GSA, there are till now about 330 Applications to deploy 5G Private Network (and the allocated frequency is still witihn the Band 42). D.S.
1/15/2021 schedule
1/ 7:00 am – 7:30am PDT
2/7:30 am – 8:00 am -PDT
Meeting Notes: The scheduled for today two (2) BPs Documentation reviews, namely IEC Type 5 and IEC Type 3, had been re-scheduled to a further date as the respective PTLs had kindly inidcated per mail that they would like to have some additional time to resolve some issues. The PTLs had been notifed in the reply that they can take their time, but hopefully, perform the Documentation review before Feb. 10th, 2021.
1/22/2021 schedule
1/ 07:00 am - 07:30 am PDT - 5G MEC/Slice System to Support Cloud Gaming, HD Video and Live Broadcasting Blueprint Zigeng Fu Feng Yang
2/ 07:30 am - 08:00 am PDT
Meeting notes:
1/29/2021 schedule
1/ 07:00 am - 07:30 am PDT
2/ 07:30 am - 08:00 am PDT
2/05/2021 schedule
1/ 07:00 am - 07:30 am PDT
2/ 07:30 am - 08:00 am PDT
Rel 3 Final Documentation and Milestone Review
Documentation Report: All the BPs besides the ones listed below are good to go:
ACRN: is listed in Release 3 planning but no activity or response
The AI Edge: School/Education Video Security Monitoring: yet to present the Documents
Public Cloud Edge Interface (PCEI) Blueprint Family: yet to present the Documents
Connected Vehicle Blueprint: Not a first release and Bluval integration is missing
IEC Type 4: AR/VR oriented Edge Stack for Integrated Edge Cloud (IEC) Blueprint Family: Not a first release and Bluval integration is missing
All PTLs please update Release 3 Planning table based on your schedule. We would like to have all PTLs make a 15 mins presentation starting Based on our meeting today, the schedule for the next meeting is below:
04/03 schedule
1/ 7:00 am – 7:15 am PDT-
2/7:15 am – 7:30 am PDT -
3/ 7:30 am- 7:45 am-
4/ 7:45 am – 8:00 am -
04/9 schedule
Agenda:
1/ 8:00 am – 8:15 am PDT-
2/8:15 am – 8:30 am PDT -
3/ 8:30 am- 8:45 am-
4/ 8:45 am – 9:00 am - Radio Edge Cloud (REC), Paul Carver
Meeting Notes:
REC Review: Paul made his presentation. There are no major changes to the BP, so he does not expect much change in any of the documents besides the Release notes and Test Document because of the mandatory Bluval validation that this BP has to meet. Release notes they would update towards the end of May when the BPs are due. Done
04/17 schedule
1/ 7:00 am – 7:15 am PDT- 5G MEC/Slice System to Support Cloud Gaming, HD Video and Live Broadcasting Blueprint, Feng Yang
2/7:15 am – 7:30 am PDT -
3/ 7:30 am- 7:45 am -
4/ 7:45 am – 8:00 am -
Meeting Notes:
5G MEC Review: Feng presented the document he had from his private space. It is not in the Documentation Template. He is going to rework his document and present it again on May 8th. In the meantime, we agreed that he will put up the draft version so that we can take a look at the material.
MEP Review: Was not present, need rescheduling.
04/24 schedule
1/ 7:00 am – 7:15 am PDT - SDN Enabled Broadband Access (SEBA) for Telco Appliance Blueprint Family Trevor Tao Cristina Pauna Song Zhu
2/7:15 am – 7:30 am PDT -
3/ 7:30 am- 7:45 am- Provider Access Edge (PAE) Blueprint Yolanda Robla Mota
4/ 7:45 am – 8:00 am -
Meeting Notes:
SEBA for Telco Appliance: The PTL changed, hence no one was present, need rescheduling.
KNI PAE: The R3 release components need to be incorporated in the architecture doc. If they have active users, they need to add end-user story under TSC>Application User Story page. They are using Openshift hence their Bluval tests are failing. Will provide the alternate validation framework that they using in the Test Document
05/01 schedule
1/ 7:00 am – 7:15 am PDT-
2/7:15 am – 7:30 am -
3/ 7:30 am- 7:45 am-
4/ 7:45 am – 8:00 am -
05/08 schedule
Adhoc session:
1/6:00 am - 6:15 am PDT - µMEC, Tapio Tallgren Ferenc Székely
1/6:15 am - 6:30 am PDT -
1/6:30 am - 6:45 am PDT - ELIOT IoT Gateway Blueprint khemendra kumar Abhijit Dasgupta
1/6:45 am - 7:00 am PDT -ELIOT SD-WAN/WAN Edge/uCPE Blueprint khemendra kumar Abhijit Dasgupta
Meeting Notes:
uMEC: Presentation was made and the following items need to be incorporated in the document:
Eliot IoT Gateway: Accepted no comments
Eliot SD-WAN/WAN Edge: Accepted no comments
Regular session:
1/ 7:00 am – 7:15 am PDT- The AI Edge: School/Education Video Security Monitoring, Hechun Zhang
2/7:15 am – 7:30 am -
3/ 7:30 am- 7:45 am- AI/ML and AR/VR applications at Edge Vikram Siwach
4/ 7:45 am – 8:00 am- Enterprise Applications on Lightweight 5G Telco Edge, khemendra kumar Abhijit Dasgupta
Meeting Notes:
AI Edge: Requested to reschedule. Will try to do an adhoc session, no more slots available
AI/ML and AR/VR: Dropped out of R3
5G Telco Edge: Architecture Doc: Integration with the Telco network for and how to manage from an Orchestrator of an Operator should be added. User plane integration point needs to be identified.
05/15 schedule
Adhoc session:
1/6:00 am - 6:15 am PDT - IEC Type 5: SmartNIC for Integrated Edge Cloud (IEC) Blueprint Family, Xuan Jia Tiejun Chen
1/6:15 am - 6:30 am PDT - Public Cloud Edge Interface (PCEI) Blueprint, Jian Li
1/6:30 am - 6:45 am PDT - Network Cloud and TF Integration Project, Sukhdev Kapur
1/6:45 am - 7:00 am PDT - 5G MEC/Slice System to Support Cloud Gaming, HD Video and Live Broadcasting Blueprint Feng Yang
Meeting Notes:
SmartNIC: Accepted no Comments
PCEI: Requested for rescheduling
Network Cloud: Accepted no Comments
5G MEC Gaming: Accepted. Will check if API Doc is valid for this BP
Regular session:
1/ 7:00 am – 7:15 am PDT- IEC Type 4: AR/VR oriented Edge Stack for Integrated Edge Cloud (IEC) Blueprint Family Thor Chin Mark Shan
2/7:15 am – 7:30 am - Intergrated Cloud Native Kuralamudhan Ramakrishnan
3/ 7:30 am- 7:45 am- Connected Vehicle Blueprint(Aka CVB) Thor Chin Jim Xu Mark Shan
4/ 7:45 am – 8:00 am - IEC Type 3: Android cloud native applications on Arm servers in edge for Integrated Edge Cloud (IEC) Blueprint Family hanyu ding wales wang
Meeting Notes:
IECC Type4 AR/VR: BluVal validation is missing. Need to execute the relevant layer validation and include in the Test Document.
ICN: No Comments
Connected Vehicle: BluVal validation is missing. Need to execute the relevant layer validation and include in the Test Document
IEC Type 3: No Comments
05/27 Meeting notes
PCEI: Oleg made a presentation of his first release. It was all in order and we have no comments from the Doc team
06/01 Meeting Notes:
AI Edge Video Security Monitoring: Presented by the team, the following are the comments
Release 2 Final Documentation and Milestone Review
11/01 -
1/ 7:00 am – 7:15 am PDT- Micro-MEC, Tapio Tallgren, (absent, rescheduled to 11/22)
2/7:15 am – 7:30 am PDT - Connected Vehicle Blueprint, xin qiu (not complete, rescheduled to 11/08)
3/ 7:30 am- 7:45 am- Radio Edge Cloud (REC), Paul Carver (absent, rescheduled to 11/22)
4/ 7:45 am – 8:00 am - Network Cloud and TF Integration Project, @Sukhdev Kapur ( great start, some requirements are not met, follow up on 11/08)
New Final Review Schedule as on 11/01
11/08- IEC Type 1 - Trevor Tao Cristina Pauna, Type 2-Cristina Pauna, xinhuili, IEC Type 4, Wen-Ping Ying Wenhui Zhang Tina Tsou, ELIOT AIOT, jereliu@tencent.com, Network Cloud and TF Integration Project, Connected Vehicle Blueprint, xin qiu,
11/15- SEBA Aaron Byrd, ICN, Kuralamudhan Ramakrishnan,
11/20- Radio Edge Cloud (REC), Paul Carver
11/22- Network Cloud Rover - David Plunkett , Network Cloud Unicycle with SR-IOV- David Plunkett, Network Cloud Unicycle with OVS-DPDK, ELIOT IOT & SDWAN, khemendra kumar,
11/29- KNI provider Access Edge, Yolanda Robla Mota, , AI ML, AR/VR application at the edge, Vikram Siwach, Radio Edge Cloud (REC), Paul Carver, IEC Type 4, Wen-Ping Ying Wenhui Zhang Tina Tsou, ELIOT AIOT, jereliu@tencent.com,
Documentation Readiness Discussion for Rel 2
10/04 - Radio Edge Cloud (REC), Paul Carver, ICN, Kuralamudhan Ramakrishnan, Network Cloud Unicycle with SR-IOVDavid Plunkett
Network Cloud and TF Integration Project, Sukhdev Kapur
10/11- Micro-MEC, Tapio Tallgren, SEBA Julie Lorentzen
10/18- IEC Type 1, Type 1, & Type 1 - Trevor Tao Cristina Pauna, xinhuili, Wen-Ping Ying Wenhui Zhang Tina Tsou,
SEBA Julie Lorentzen , ICN, Kuralamudhan Ramakrishnan,
10/25-AI/ML, AR/VR application at the edge, Vikram Siwach, ELIOT AIOT, IOT, SDWAN, Guoxu (Jeremy) Liu, khemendra kumar, Network Cloud and TF Integration Project, Sukhdev Kapur, KNI provider Access Edge, Yolanda Robla Mota, Connected Vehicle Blueprint, xin qiu , Network Cloud Rover, David Plunkett Starling X Bill Zvonar, IEC Type 2 Pauna, xinhuili,
07/18 7:00 am PDT Rel 2 Milestones and Planning
Documentation Readiness Discussion for Rel 1
04/26 7:00 am PDT – Unicycle for NEC & Rover Blueprint Proposal for Addition to Network Cloud Blueprint Family -david.plunkett@att.com
05/03 7:00 am PDT- OVS-DPDK Unicycle Dell Blueprint Proposal- Rakesh Bohra <rakesh.bohra@ericsson.com>,
StarlingX Far Edge Distributed Cloud - Bill Zvonar,
Eliot- Abhijit
05/10 7:00 am PDT – Kubernetes-Native Infrastructure for Edge (KNI-Edge) Family,
05/17 7:00 am PDT – Edge Video Processing- adnan.saleem@radisys.com, IEC Type 1 for Integrated Edge Cloud (IEC) Blueprint Family- trevor.tao@arm.com
05/24 6:00 am PDT –
IEC Type 2 for Integrated Edge Cloud (IEC) Blueprint Family- lxinhui@vmware.com,
Edge Video Processing- adnan.saleem@radisys.com,
IEC Type 1 for Integrated Edge Cloud (IEC) Blueprint Family- trevor.tao@arm.com
Eliot IoT Gateway- khemendra.kumar@huawei.com
7:00 am PDT
Review Architecture Document, Test Document, Release Notes, Installation Guide which are sub-linked to this page.
Review Akraino Project Reporting
Meeting Content (minutes / recording / slides / other):